5 Dollars Rutherford B. Hayes

Liberia has issued commemorative five-dollar pieces honoring American presidents since the 1990s, producing them in bulk for the collector novelty market rather than domestic circulation. Hayes himself is an odd choice for celebration — his presidency is best remembered for ending Reconstruction in 1877 by withdrawing federal troops from the South, a decision with consequences far more significant than his one term suggested. The Liberia connection to American history runs deeper than most buyers of these pieces realize: the republic was founded in 1847 by formerly enslaved Americans, making the political symbolism of a Hayes commemorative quietly uncomfortable.